Incarceron by Catherine Fisher

Reviewed by Lori
Incarceron
Title: Incarceron

Author: Catherine Fisher

Perma-Bound Catalogue #: 41041

Description:  To free herself from an upcoming arranged marriage, Claudia, the daughter of the Warden of Incarceron, a futuristic prison with a mind of its own, decides to help a young prisoner escape.

Rubric Rating: Level 2: Like It

Why I Read It: I loved this book's cover and title and that's the reason I started this novel.   I was captivated by the beautiful key and I liked that the companion novel's cover shows a keyhole.

Lori's Notes:  I'm sad that the inside of the book didn't live up to the outside for me.  A living prison and social experiment, Incarceron has been sealed for centuries and no one has escaped. Claudia, the warden's daughter wants to escape an arranged marriage and through the use of a crystal key meets Finn, trapped within the prison.  Finn has no idea whom he is or how he ended up in Incarceron.  Each day is a struggle for survival but with Claudia and the sapient Jared's help, Finn and his friends might just be able to escape the prison.  A prison that has ideas of its own.  A typical hero's journey with the hero/heroine,  mage, trickster, thief, and the evil villain. While the premise of this story was incredibly interesting I found the setting of the story confusing.  The story takes place in the future; however, the time period chosen as ideal is a medieval period so the women and men are dressed in period costume, they live in a castle with feudal serfs, and must practice the social mores of that time period.  I found the dichotomy of a future dystopian set in an historical time frame more than a little jarring.  Particularly, the fact that the characters who seemed to idealize the medieval period fail to take proper care of the technology that allows them to continue the pretense of this fabricated world.  In fact it took me quite some time to realize that the novel was not set in the past but rather in a future looking backward.  Juxtapose that with a shift between the "historical world" and the "prison world" and it becomes even more confusing.  I also would have liked more information about why Incarceron was set up as a social experiment -- not just a prison. While I am a fan of the Dystopian genre I felt that this book missed the mark.

Recommended Reader:  This novel is probably best for individual reading for Grade 7 and up. Because there was some confusion with regard to time/place I would recommend this book for an experienced reader.

Themes: Hero's Journey, Self-Discovery, Truth and justice, Relationships, Dystopian, Prisons and Prisoners, Arranged Marriage, Individual Rights, Orphans, Mutants, Secrets, Identity.

Cross-Genre Links:
Web Search:  Stanford Prison Experiment
Movie: The Experiment (2010)
Movie: Pleasantville (1998)
Movie: The Cube (1997)
Music: Care of Cell 44 by the Zombies (1967)

Possible Essay or Discussion Topics: 

  • What is Incarceron?
  • Did you think the novel was set in the future or the past when your first started reading? What made you think so?  
  • Why would society decide to pick one time period in history and not move forward?  (Discuss the implications for the use of technology)
  • Who is Finn?  What makes you think so?
  • Explain how Finn and Claudia are both facing Incarceron.  How are they both prisoners?

Other Books in this Series:

Other Titles by Catherine Fisher:

Series: The Obsidian Mirror

Series: Relic Master




Comments

Post a Comment

Thank you for Reading!

Popular posts from this blog

Bluffton by Matt Phelan

Reviewed by Lori
Image
Title:  Bluffton: My Summers with Buster Author:  Matt Phelan Perma-Bound Catalogue #: 138305 Description:    Henry bonds with a young Buster Keaton over games of baseball while the latter summers locally with a troupe of vaudeville performers. Rubric Rating:   Level 3 - Laud It Why I Read It:  A growing interest in Graphic novels and a fascination with silent films. Notes:   I really liked this graphic novel.  The images are soft – softly coloured and softly focused.  This is the story of Henry Harrison and the summers that Buster Keaton and the Vaudeville troop come and stay at Bluffton.  While Henry is a fictional character Buster Keaton is not and the novel is based on his autobiography. The arrival of Buster brings excitement to Henry’s life.  They fill their summer days with baseball, pratfalls, and pranks. When Buster leaves for the show, Henry’s life returns to normal, helping his father at the har...
Read more

Cardturner by Louis Sachar

Reviewed by Lori
Image
Title: Cardturner Author: Louis Sachar Perma-Bound Catalogue #: 43908 Description: When his wealthy uncle, a champion bridge player who has lost his vision, asks seventeen-year-old Alton to be a cardturner for him, Alton has no idea how much he will ultimately learn from his eccentric relative.  Includes appendix by Syd Fox with information about bridge. Rubric Rating: Level 3 - Laud It Why I Read It: I really enjoyed the novel Holes and this book is by the same author. Lori's Notes: Alton's rich uncle, a champion bridge player, is blind and needs a cardturner for him to play.  A fantastic story about families and relationships, it weaves together the storylines of Alton and his uncle and first loves.  It does delve a little into the paranormal/ghostly but it wasn't distracting to the overall sense of the novel.  It also touches on the idea of how relationships change and change us.  I'm not a bridge player at all and had no idea how the game was p...
Read more

Finding Reading a Challenge During a Pandemic

Reviewed by Lori
Image
I love reading.  I have always loved reading.  But reading during a pandemic has been more than a little bit challenging.   Between worries and distractions my mind is constantly somewhere else.  I've found that I can't sustain my focus for more than a chapter or two.  I pick up a book, I put it down.  Then I struggle to remember what I just read, so I have to start all over again.  I've tried new books, old favourites, audio books, and ebooks.  The result is always the same, another book added to the "to be finished" pile.  And it isn't like I don't have the time to read, I have scads of it.  But then I'm never alone and the moment I pick up a book to try again, someone and/or something needs my attention and whatever little time I had to myself has now blown away like dandelion seeds in a stiff breeze.   You'd think given the situation, with multiple lockdowns and unending time at home, I would use reading as an escape -...
Read more